Site Checkups report
designisnotui.com
A sharp, well-argued essay that earns agreement, but the only path to Synergy is a closing link that never says what Synergy sells.
Clear
A sharp, well-argued essay that earns agreement, but the only path to Synergy is a closing link that never says what Synergy sells.
No blockers, so no points against it. Nothing on this page stops people from buying, but 7 things make people hesitate. The grade counts blockers only.
Fix these first
In order. Each one keeps its number where it appears in the report.
- Fix first, number 1Trust gapAn essay built on "Strategic judgment is earned, not installed" asks readers to trust earned experience, yet the shown text offers no named author, bio or track record to back the voice, which weakens it as something to forward to a skeptical boss.
- Fix first, number 2Button problem"Learn more about Synergy →" is the only path to the company, and since the page never says what Synergy offers, readers who liked the essay have no reason to expect anything specific on the other side.
- Fix first, number 3Hesitation“Who is actually saying this?” The essay speaks as "we" and leans on experience ("Judgment is not a tool. It is earned over years"), but the shown text names no person whose years those are.
Conversion blockers· 0
Nothing here stops someone who came to buy
The grade comes from these alone, each weighted from 1 (minor) to 5 (critical).
None found. Nothing on this page should stop someone who came to buy.
How your page reads
What a first-time visitor takes away
To a first-time visitor
This reads as a confident manifesto, not a sales page, and "10 min read" sets that expectation early. Designers who've been arguing this point at work will feel seen and keep scrolling. People looking for a product or service will leave fast, because nothing up top says one exists.
In the first five seconds
It's an opinion essay arguing that design is judgment and strategy, not screens, and that AI can't replace that judgment.
What visitors think you offer
A free essay defending product design against AI-first thinking, meant to be read and shared.
What you actually offer
A free position essay from Synergy, which also publishes a design principles library and a companion essay, "It's OK to be human", with a link to learn more about Synergy.
Readers finish knowing the argument but not what Synergy is.
Synergy appears only in the footer, the principles section and "Learn more about Synergy →", and the shown text never says whether Synergy is a studio, a product or a publisher, so interested readers can't judge if following up is worth a click.
The "What's this? Scroll down to find out." teaser promises an explanation of the page itself, and readers who don't reach the "What This Is" section may never learn who's behind it.
The principle behind thisSerial Position EffectFrom a list, people recall the opening items and the closing ones. What's in between slips.The research behind it →
What's working· 3
Keep these as they are
The opening lines "UI is what a product looks like. Design is the judgment about what it should be, and why." state the whole position in two sentences, so readers know instantly whether they agree.
The closing "If you keep having this argument at work, share this page and let it make the case for you." gives the target reader a concrete reason to act, matching the page's real goal.
Citing Des Traynor, Jared Spool, Roger Martin and Julie Zhuo, plus Synergy's own principles pages, makes the argument feel researched rather than opinion.
Visitor hesitations· 2
Readers can't tell who wrote this or why.
Fix first, number 3Who is actually saying this?
The essay speaks as "we" and leans on experience ("Judgment is not a tool. It is earned over years"), but the shown text names no person whose years those are.
Are these quote buttons something I click?
Lines like "What user data led us to this specific layout?" are listed as buttons, and the text doesn't make clear whether they copy, expand or just display.
Trust gaps· 1
The essay has no named author behind its strong claims.
- Fix first, number 1
An essay built on "Strategic judgment is earned, not installed" asks readers to trust earned experience, yet the shown text offers no named author, bio or track record to back the voice, which weakens it as something to forward to a skeptical boss.
The principle behind thisSocial ProofWhen people aren't sure what to do, they look at what people like them did.The research behind it →
Button problems· 2
The Synergy link asks for interest without saying what's there.
- Fix first, number 2
"Learn more about Synergy →" is the only path to the company, and since the page never says what Synergy offers, readers who liked the essay have no reason to expect anything specific on the other side.
"Share" and the link to "It's OK to be human" sit in the same closing stretch as the Synergy link, and the text doesn't make clear which of the three the page most wants, so the company link competes with two easier actions.
The principle behind thisHick's LawThe more choices people have, and the harder they are, the longer it takes to decide.The research behind it →

